The 10 Best 4-Slice Toasters

Updated May 22, 2018 by Christopher Thomas

10 Best 4-Slice Toasters
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive
We spent 40 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top options for this wiki. There's nothing like the aroma and crunchy/chewy texture of freshly buttered toast. If two slices isn't enough for you or you've got several mouths to feed, check out these 4-slice toasters. They'll let you make breakfast for you and the family a whole lot quicker, and can handle everything from regular sandwich bread to thick bakery slices, bagels, and more. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best 4-slice toaster on Amazon.

10. Proctor Silex 24201

Available in black or white, the no-frills Proctor Silex 24201 will help feed you in the mornings without starving your wallet. Its simple design means it's easy to use and doesn't have a host of complicated features that might get in the way.
  • exterior stays cool to the touch
  • might only last a year or so
  • cord is less than a foot long
Brand Proctor Silex
Model 24201
Weight 4.9 pounds
Rating 3.7 / 5.0

9. Hamilton Beach Cool Touch

Prepare breakfast quickly and easily with the multifunctional Hamilton Beach Cool Touch. It gets the job done at an extremely affordable price, but doesn't have the most eye-catching design, which may turn off some potential buyers.
  • easy to retrieve bread when ready
  • built-in settings for frozen items
  • power cord is a bit short
Brand Hamilton Beach
Model 24121
Weight 6.1 pounds
Rating 3.7 / 5.0

8. Hamilton Beach Long Slot

Nothing beats melted butter, and the Hamilton Beach Long Slot's keep warm feature affords you up to three extra minutes of prep time while your toast is waiting to be slathered. Its elongated design means it'll take even the widest slices of homemade bread.
  • very economical price
  • beeps way too much
  • lighter and less stable than others
Brand Hamilton Beach
Model 24810
Weight 5.8 pounds
Rating 4.1 / 5.0

7. Krups Breakfast Set

The Krups Breakfast Set is an attractive option for the modern family, featuring two separate heating zones with several settings and a user-friendly design. The bagel function crisps one side while warming the other for the tastiest results.
  • controls are simple to adjust
  • stylish blue led indicator lights
  • somewhat slower than other models
Model 1500578368
Weight 7.2 pounds
Rating 3.8 / 5.0

6. Cuisinart CPT-180

The Cuisinart CPT-180 sports a classic retro feel in a compact size that doesn't take up too much counter space. Its smooth brushed stainless steel housing with polished chrome and black accents will blend in nicely with most decor.
  • comes with a 3-year warranty
  • extra-wide slots
  • crumb tray pulls out from the back
Brand Cuisinart
Model CPT-180
Weight 6.4 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

5. Oxo Lever-Free

Simplify your morning routine with the Oxo Lever-Free, which features a quiet motor that gently lowers and raises bread automatically. You can also easily add 30 seconds to the cycle if your toast is not quite crisp enough when it pops up the first time.
  • ready notification beep
  • easy to read countdown timer
  • stainless steel body resists smudges
Brand OXO
Model 8710500
Weight 11.3 pounds
Rating 5.0 / 5.0

4. West Bend TEM4500W

The West Bend TEM4500W may be the mother of all toasters. This beautiful machine's got your sandwich covered from muffin to meat to sunny-side-up, all in one magical package. It's the perfect gift for the breakfast lover in your life, even if that happens to be yourself.
  • steaming tray for sausage patties
  • poaches or fries or hard-boils eggs
  • you may want to upgrade the pans
Brand West Bend
Model TEM4500W
Weight 8.6 pounds
Rating 4.3 / 5.0

3. Dualit NewGen

The one-of-a-kind Dualit NewGen offers impeccable craftsmanship, from individual slot selection to a reliable mechanical timer and ejection system. While it is quite expensive, it shows us that even toasters can be works of art.
  • chic industrial vibe
  • matching sandwich cage available
  • comes in a huge variety of colors
Brand Dualit
Model 47440
Weight 10.3 pounds
Rating 4.9 / 5.0

2. Russell Hobbs Retro

Transport your kitchen back to the diners of the 1950s with the Russell Hobbs Retro. Not only is this one snazzy-looking appliance, it's also notably faster than most other choices. It has a defrost setting that helps you get the perfect crunch from frozen bread, too.
  • choose from a red or black finish
  • accepts slices up to 3 cm thick
  • toast in under 2 minutes
Brand Russell Hobbs
Model TR9250RDR
Weight 9.6 pounds
Rating 4.7 / 5.0

1. Breville Smart

Promising consistent cooking over a long lifespan, the Breville Smart is a sleek and reliable choice. Rather than having four separate slots for each item, it uses two at double the standard length, allowing room for hot dog buns and artisan bread.
  • led progress indicator
  • adjustable ready alert volume
  • leads the pack in browning evenness
Brand Breville
Model BTA830XL
Weight 12.1 pounds
Rating 4.9 / 5.0

A Four Slice Toaster: The Appliance You Didn't Know You Were Missing

This might come as something of a surprise, but the average toaster requires at least three and a half minutes to toast a decent slice of bread. In fact, a group of scientists even conducted a study testing thousands of slices of toast made in dozens of toasters and concluded that, based on an array of metrics including everything from golden-brown color to external crunch and internal softness, the ideal slice of toast cooks in a toaster for exactly 216 seconds.

That's the better part of four minutes, meaning that if you would like to serve two people two slices of toast each, you will have to wait around for no fewer than seven minutes and 12 seconds for all four pieces of bread to be ready. That is, assuming you are using a standard two slice toaster. With a good four slice toaster, on the other hand, your breakfast platter or club sandwich lunch will be ready twice as fast.

One important to thing to keep in mind is that four slice toasters are never twice as expensive as two slice options; in fact, on average they are only about 30 percent higher in cost. Most two slice toasters operate at an average power consumption of around 1,200 watts. While a four slice model certainly uses more power, it does not use twice as much energy as its smaller counterpart. So, ultimately, preparing four slices of toast (or four waffles or two sliced bagels) at once is not only more efficient in terms of time saved, but also in reduced energy consumption and operating cost — that's good for the planet and for your bank account, too.

Once you are convinced that a toaster with four slots is the right appliance for your household, it's time to choose the right device. In most cases, there's little need for a toaster at the very top end of the price range, but if you regularly prepare bagels, waffles, toasted tarts, and bread, buying at least a midrange toaster is generally advised. Any decent toaster will have a dial to control its heating time and a removable tray for cleaning fallen crumbs from the unit. Also, look for features such as pre-set bagel or frozen food programs that will remove much of the guesswork from the toasting process.

Ultimately, you will likely find several toasters with similar functions in similar price brackets. If your toaster will usually live on the kitchen counter, then it's easy to justify spending extra cash for an appliance that looks handsome. A unit with a brushed stainless steel exterior is always a fine choice. For the toaster that will spend most of the time in a drawer or cabinet, looks are an afterthought; find the unit with the right features and the lowest cost.

Toaster Safety 101

Under normal conditions, using a toaster is a safe and simple affair. But as logic would dictate, any appliance that uses copious amounts of electricity and produces a high volume of heat can indeed be a safety hazard. So, take a few simple precautions to ensure that your toaster helps you make plenty of warm, tasty bagels and breads and never presents a danger to your home, friends, and family.

The first step to toaster safety is also the simplest: when you are not actively using your toaster, it should always be unplugged. This removes the possibility for the appliance to be accidentally activated, possibly while in close proximity to flammable materials like paper towels or cereal boxes, and it removes the chance of electric shock or an electrical fire. Also, be sure to move any and all potentially flammable materials away from your toaster before activating it. This includes napkins, wooden knife blocks and cutting boards, and other common kitchen items.

In the rare instance that a toaster does produce a fire, it's a wise idea to have a fire extinguisher on hand.. (Of course it's wise to have an extinguisher in any kitchen in general.)

Never try to clear a jam or clean out a toaster that is plugged into the wall, and always give a toaster at least four or five minutes after it has been disconnected from its power source before you attempt to service or clean it. A toaster can deliver a severe shock if its internal components are touched while it is plugged in, and lingering heat can cause an injury even well after the device was last used.

A Brief History Of Toasting Bread

Human beings have been baking and enjoying bread for tens of thousands of years. Heating prepared bread further, until it takes on a pleasant, toasted character is likewise not a recent development, with references to toasted bread dating back at least as far as the Middle Ages.

The popularity of toast as an everyday foodstuff grew greatly during the 1800s, and many devices were developed to aid in the preparation of this enjoyable source of carbohydrates. Early toasters were essentially nothing more than wire baskets with handles that allowed a slice of bread to be held over an open fire or slid into a heated oven. The results were much the same as we know toast today, but the process was labor-intensive in the utmost.

The world's first recognized electric toaster was developed by a Scotsman named Alan MacMasters in the year 1893. His appliance was effective, but not durable, with the heating elements -- often made of iron -- subject to accidental melting. Developments in ever better elements using alloys led to safer, more stable toasters released in the early years of the 20th century.

The first pop-up toaster was developed by an American named Charles Strite who patented his now ubiquitous device in 1921. Toaster development throughout the rest of the century (and into the current era) mirrored other advances in technology at large, including the use of digital controls, LED indication lights, and ever-safer electrical components.

Statistics and Editorial Log

Paid Placements

Recent Update Frequency

help support our research

patreon logoezvid wiki logo small

Last updated on May 22, 2018 by Christopher Thomas

A traveling chef, musician, and student of the English language, Chris can be found promoting facts and perfect copy around the globe, from dense urban centers to remote mountaintops. In his free time he revels in dispelling pseudoscience, while at night he dreams of modern technology, world peace, and the Oxford comma.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.