Updated December 20, 2019 by Daniel Imperiale

The 10 Best Electronic Drum Sets

video play icon

This wiki has been updated 26 times since it was first published in March of 2015. Percussion is an integral part of most genres of music, but it's often difficult, inappropriate, or simply impossible to practice or record with a large, acoustic kit. Any of these electronic drum sets will allow amateur and professional musicians to play virtually anywhere, as they are lightweight and compact and can be played with headphones on, so you don't disturb the neighbors. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to help fund the Wiki. If you'd like to contribute your own research to the Wiki, please get started by reviewing this introductory video.

1. Yamaha DTX920 HWK

2. Alesis DM10 MKII Studio Kit

3. Roland TD-25KVX

Editor's Notes

December 19, 2019:

There were a lot of upgrades to this list, causing us to send several popular models packing, like the Yamaha DTX450K, in favor of their upgraded versions. We also saw fit to remove some underperforming models, like the Alesis Strike Pro, which suffered from a lot of trigger malfunctions that are not the norm for the company.

While there are still purists out there who haven't joined the mesh revolution and are still clinging desperately to their rubber pads, we are unequivocally proponents of mesh on any and all electronic drum heads, even if cheaper attempts at the technology can cause some issues with triggering that inexpensive rubber doesn't suffer. At the end of the day we're looking for the best options out there, so cheap models aren't liable to make our ranking to begin with.

Beyond that particular feature, we took a close look at polyphonic capabilities, as a low or poor-performing polyphony could cause some hits to fail to register, or to blend together in unnatural ways, causing a kick to cut off when you hit the ride, for example. We also considered total available voices, as a small bank of these would seriously inhibit a musician's ability to find his or her own sound. To that end, the Yamaha DTX920 HWK is especially impressive, with over 1,000 available sounds for its responsive kit. The Roland V-Drums TD50 KVX also offers an impressive array of kits, numbering over 400, and its hi-hat has one of the most natural sounds and feels of anything in the electronic market. Of course, its price reflects these features, and holds it back from being a top contender for the masses. Little things added up, as well, like whether or not a set came with a kick pedal or a throne, but ultimately it was the performance of each that dictated their ranking.

4. Roland V-Drums TD50 KVX

5. Alesis Command Mesh Kit

6. Yamaha Electronic DTX452K

7. Roland V Entry Electronic

8. Yamaha Electronic DTX402K

9. Carlsbro CSD500 XXX

10. Alesis Nitro Eight Piece

Fingers On The Trigger

Electronic drums operate on the principal of what are commonly called triggers.

Electronic drums operate on the principal of what are commonly called triggers. There's no violence implied here. It's more like hitting a big red button than firing a gun.

When you hit a drum trigger, or pad, the intensity of the hit – and sometimes even its exact position on the pad – is relayed to a module of available sounds and translated through any number of presets you select.

The thing about most electronic drums is that you can assign that trigger to make any sound under the sun so long as it's programmed into your module.

Most people will give the pad in the snare position a snare sound, the tom positions tom sounds, the ride cymbal a ride cymbal sound, etc., until they essentially have a recreation of a standard drum kit in front of them.

That's fine and all, but you can really customize these sounds to anything and everything. If you want your snare to sound like a kick drum and your kick drum to sound like a spaceship launching or a geisha fanning herself, there's nothing but your budget to stop you.

Zen And The Art Of Electronic Drumming

Most drummers will tell you, especially if they're rock or jazz drummers, that there is no substitute for a real acoustic kit. It's not just the sound they're talking about, either.

They're liable to go off on a long pseudo-spiritual rant about the life force in a "real" drum set.

There's a great Robert Pirsig quote about this mentality in his spiritual road epic Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, in which he's undoubtedly paraphrasing a Zen parable he heard along the way.

With the spiritual stuff out of the way, we can admit that there are significant sonic differences between acoustic and electric drums.

He says, "The only zen you find on tops of mountains is the zen you bring up there."

What it means for us is that there's nothing inherently more spiritual about an acoustic drum than a electronic drum, it's just that we find it easier to connect them to things we view as living, namely trees. But steel and plastics are just as spiritually and practically alive as any redwood. It's what you bring to the experience that matters.

With the spiritual stuff out of the way, we can admit that there are significant sonic differences between acoustic and electric drums.

In the case of acoustics, the sound of the drum is largely determined by its environment: the size of the room, the moisture in the air, etc. But you are in complete control of the sonic output of your electronic drums.

You can fine tune an electric kit to sound like an old GMS kit in a 1000-square-foot barn on the driest day of the summer if you want to spend enough on the tech side of it.

In that sense, electronic drum sets are all about customization. The more custom you want the sound and feel, the nicer a kit you're going to want.

If it's really just a matter of getting your hands on something that'll let you rock out without disturbing the peace, you'll be happy with something less expensive.

Rhythm From A Box

In the early 1960s musicians and artists began to experiment increasingly with devices called rhythm boxes. They were essentially early drum machines made by companies like Maestro and Ace Tone.

In the early 1960s musicians and artists began to experiment increasingly with devices called rhythm boxes.

One such drummer, a man named Felix Visser, modified an Ace Tone drum machine to respond whenever he touched any one of a dozen circuits he wired into a board.

There was no pressure sensitivity, and the sound quality was immensely mechanical, but it was the dawn of electronic drumming as we know it.

It wasn't until 1971, however, that a drum trigger pad, designed to be hit with a drumstick, came into being. A Sussex University professor named Brian Groves combined his technical knowledge with the ambition and imagination of the drummer from The Moody Blues, Graeme Edge.

Since then, the pads have become more sensitive and more elaborate, the sounds have been more fine tuned to sound like human productions and not the effort of machines, and the feel of the drums themselves has gotten closer and closer to the feel of actual acoustic drum sets.

Daniel Imperiale
Last updated on December 20, 2019 by Daniel Imperiale

Daniel Imperiale holds a bachelor’s degree in writing, and proudly fled his graduate program in poetry to pursue a quiet life at a remote Alaskan fishery. After returning to the contiguous states, he took up a position as an editor and photographer of the prestigious geek culture magazine “Unwinnable” before turning his attention to the field of health and wellness. In recent years, he has worked extensively in film and music production, making him something of a know-it-all when it comes to camera equipment, musical instruments, recording devices, and other audio-visual hardware. Daniel’s recent obsessions include horology (making him a pro when it comes to all things timekeeping) and Uranium mining and enrichment (which hasn’t proven useful just yet).

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For more information on our rankings, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.