The 10 Best Animal Traps

video play icon

This wiki has been updated 30 times since it was first published in June of 2015. Anyone who’s ever spent the spring preparing a beautiful garden full of fruits and vegetables only to see it ravaged by pests will tell you that an animal trap can be a great help. Many of these are designed for catch and release captures, as they allow you to relocate the critters in a safe and humane manner. Just make sure to practice caution, as some can cause accidental injury. When users buy our independently chosen editorial selections, we may earn commissions to help fund the Wiki.

1. Tru Catch Live

2. Kensizer Humane

3. Duke Coil 1

This item has been flagged for editorial review and is not available.

Editor's Notes

May 07, 2020:

Reports of sharp edges inside the Trapro Collapsible led to its removal, as it can pose a danger to the critter trapped inside it (thus defeating the purpose of a humane trap). We also eliminated the Ranger Products Humane, Amagabeli Garden & Home Live, and Havahart 1079 Woodstream due to a variety of issues, including poor durability and the tendency to let animals escape.

We brought the listing for the Hux Eye Clear up to date, indicating that the latest version of the trap features additional air holes — which were added to address complaints that the air holes in the previous version were not sufficient. While the AB Traps Pro is a basic model with a single door, it’s also available in an extended, double-door design that will cost a bit extra.

Knowing that most of the items on the list are catch-and-release cage models, we decided to add some diversity to the rankings with the Duke 0480 (a powerful body-gripping trap that instantly kills the animal) and the Duke Coil 1, a foot-hold restraining trap. Both are quite powerful and require caution during setup to avoid injuries.

Pro tip we picked up during our research: if you’re having trouble using your trap to catch shrewd, old rats, try leaving treats in the cage for a few days without setting the trigger. Once the rodent becomes comfortable snatching the free snacks and lets its guard down, set the rat trap and reap the rewards.

Special Honors

Nixalite Live Capture In addition to a wide range of traps for capturing small rodents (like rats and gophers) and bigger animals (like groundhogs and skunks), Nixalite offers several models designed for safely catching and releasing snakes. One of the traps even prevents skunks from lifting their tails and spraying while in captivity.

H.B. Sherman Traps Since 1955, H.B. Sherman has been supplying government departments, commercial organizations and even the U.S. military with traps that can efficiently capture a variety of animals in a humane, environmentally friendly way. Folding traps, non-folding traps, and individual parts are available for purchase.

PAWS Feral Cat Trap Rental If you’re looking to relocate feral cats that have been lingering on your property, you don’t necessarily need to go out and buy a trap; PAWS rents them out for a relatively small fee in many of its locations across the country. Just make sure to check your local ordinances to make sure trapping cats in your area is legal.

4. AB Traps Pro

5. AllRoad Outdoor

6. Havahart 1045

7. Duke 0480

This item has been flagged for editorial review and is not available.

8. Havahart 0745

9. HomGarden Release

10. Hux Eye Clear

A Brief History Of Animal Traps

Of course, if cartoons have taught us anything, it's that the raccoon will hilariously turn the trap around on you somehow, so be careful.

The first known use of traps dates back to the Neolithic era, sometime around 5500 B.C.E. People around this time would use crude nets to ensnare their victims, or disguise pits with the intention of chasing prey into them. None of these tactics were terribly elaborate, but what was more important is that they were effective.

Soon, however, the widespread use of weapons — first spears, and later bows and arrows — caused trapping to fall out of favor. Hunting had one major disadvantage, however: it was incredibly time-consuming. With trapping, you could set multiple snares and then check them at a later date, giving you time to do other things, such as farm and, apparently, graffiti cave walls.

Around the 16th century C.E., new technology — specifically the steel-jawed trap — allowed hunters to securely hold animals until such time as they could be harvested, so the meat would stay fresh. The first spring-loaded mousetrap was invented around this time, as well, and people began to trap and kill pests in addition to food.

It was in the American West that trapping would come into its own, however. Native American tribes had long used pits, snares, and the like to hunt animals, but as Europeans came flooding into the continent and the idea of Manifest Destiny took hold in Americans, more and more people began venturing into uncharted — and untamed — territory.

These explorers needed a reliable way to catch food, and they used the furs and pelts of trapped animals to finance their expeditions. Fur trading outposts began to crop up all over the western United States and Canada; these stations allowed settlers to trade with native tribes, as well as establish territorial claims for their countries.

Beyond aiding with exploration, trappers and mountain men helped pave the way for settlers to follow them. By keeping local wildlife populations under control, they enabled farms and other settlements to become established without constantly being threatened by dangerous animals.

Once the West was finally tamed, trapping began to recede in the popular consciousness again. Today, most trapping is done for pest control purposes, or with the intention of relocating the animal to a safer location. The use of traps is heavily regulated, and the only interaction the average person will have with one is when they need to catch that pesky raccoon that's digging up their flower bed.

Of course, if cartoons have taught us anything, it's that the raccoon will hilariously turn the trap around on you somehow, so be careful.

Tips For Successful Trapping

Below are some tips you can use to ensure that your trapping efforts are successful — and that you don't end up accidentally snagging the neighbor's cat (unless you really want to, that is).

The first step is to determine what exactly you're dealing with as different animals require different traps. Tunnels indicate the presence of rodents, while knocked-over garbage bins are a telltale sign of raccoons. If your taller plants are being nibbled on, you might have deer to deal with, so you'll either need a different strategy or much bigger traps.

Once you know the approximate size of the pests you're going to be trapping, purchase a model that's big enough to fit them — but not much bigger.

Once you know the approximate size of the pests you're going to be trapping, purchase a model that's big enough to fit them — but not much bigger. You don't want them to have a lot of room to move, as they can injure themselves trying to escape, not to mention hurt you when it's time to relocate them.

Leave the trap somewhere along the animal's likely path, such as near its burrow or close to its food or water source. Make sure that it's away from any high-traffic area, or you'll spook the little critter and end up catching nothing.

From there, it's simply a matter of choosing a bait they won't be able to resist and setting the trap. Check it frequently; you don't want to leave the animal in there too long, as it can become terrified or even die. Likewise, if you're not catching anything, you'll want to know as soon as possible, so you can re-think your strategy.

Oh, and be sure to wear a coonskin cap and refer to yourself as "Trapper" the entire time, or no one will take you seriously.

How To Handle A Trapped Animal

Before we share tips for handling an animal you've captured, it's probably important that we remind you that the best way to handle a trapped animal is to not handle a trapped animal. Call the professionals, such as your local animal control service.

If the animal shows any indication of being sick, don't release it at all.

If you insist, however, be extremely careful. You may have the best of intentions for the trapped little fella, but he doesn't know that — and he's likely to try every method at his disposal to discourage you. Wear heavy gloves, and keep any exposed skin well away from the animal's claws and jaws.

No matter how cute the creature — or how heavy your gloves — do not pet or handle it in any way. You don't know what diseases it might be carrying, and many of them (like rabies) are no joke.

If the animal shows any indication of being sick, don't release it at all. Instead, call animal control and let them deal with it.

Once the animal has been released from your trap, disinfect the entire thing with a bleach solution. This is for your safety as well as that of future animals, so don't skimp on this step. Once you're finished, wash your hands thoroughly.

While trapping and releasing animals can be a humane way to deal with a pest problem, it's not without its dangers. Whatever you decide, be careful, and keep your own safety as your primary consideration. After all, you started that garden to improve your health, so the last thing you want to end up growing is the Hanta virus.

Sam Kraft
Last updated by Sam Kraft

In addition to his corporate career as a marketing and communications professional in Chicago, Sam runs a popular blog that focuses on the city’s flourishing craft beer and brewery scene. He received his degree in journalism from DePaul University (which spurred his interest in freelance writing) and has since spent years developing expertise in copywriting, digital marketing and public relations. A lifetime of fishing, hiking and camping trips has left him well-versed in just about any outdoors-related topic, and over several years spent working in the trades during his youth, he accumulated a wealth of knowledge about tools and machinery. He’s a travel junkie, a health and fitness enthusiast, and an avid biker.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For more information on our rankings, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.