10 Best Balsamic Vinegars | April 2017

We spent 33 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top choices for this wiki. The balsamic vinegar you get in most grocery stores tastes like little more than colored white vinegar; it's too acidic to provide even minimal complexity. Traditional balsamic vinegar, on the other hand, like those that dominate our list, are thick, sweet, and exploding with individual characteristics specific to their unique processing. We've rated them here by flavor, complexity, and value. Skip to the best balsamic vinegar on Amazon.
10 Best Balsamic Vinegars | April 2017
Overall Rank: 4
Best Mid-Range
★★★★
Overall Rank: 1
Best High-End
★★★★★
Overall Rank: 8
Best Inexpensive
★★★
10
Good for serving on cuts of premium beef or over ice cream, the La Piana Gold is imported directly from Italy and made from the must of Modena grapes that are carefully cooked and then slow-aged in wooden barrels over time.
  • has a velvety texture
  • process intensifies flavor
  • top is hard to open
Brand La Piana
Model pending
Weight 1.6 pounds
Rating 3.9 / 5.0
9
Individually signed, numbered, and made in small batches, the MiaBella Traditional is delivered to you in this artistically-crafted dark bottle with a cork stopper. It's made from 100% Trebbiano grapes with no added preservatives.
  • below 5 percent acidity level
  • friendly customer service
  • lacks aged complexity
Brand MiaBella
Model MB1
Weight 1.3 pounds
Rating 4.1 / 5.0
8
The Gourmet Living Goccia de Oro has been crafted from the barrel-aged wine must of Lambrusco grapes that are grown and harvested in Italy. It is also IGP certified, so you know you can trust the company, and it makes a good flavor enhancer for your meals.
  • mid-grade choice for chefs
  • packaging is aesthetically pleasing
  • consistency is a little thin
Brand Gourmet Living
Model pending
Weight 1.9 pounds
Rating 3.6 / 5.0
7
Dense in texture and with a pleasantly sweet aftertaste, the Giuseppe Giusti pairs exceptionally well with barbecued meats and can even double as standalone sauce. Its flavors are reminiscent of plum jam, honey, and vanilla.
  • company founded in 1605
  • supports sustainable agriculture
  • the bottle is kind of bulky
Brand Guiseppe Giusti
Model pending
Weight 1.7 pounds
Rating 3.6 / 5.0
6
Full flavored, sapid, and with velvety undertones, the Fattoria Estense Manicardi Extravecchio brings with it a history of tradition and consistency. Just a light drizzle goes a long way over your favorite cheeses and berries.
  • 100 ml capacity
  • aged over 25 years
  • steep price point
Brand Fattoria Estense
Model pending
Weight 4 ounces
Rating 3.9 / 5.0
5
If you want access to high-quality, time-tempered flavor without a ridiculous price tag, the Villa Manodori 2 Bottle Set provides you with a pair of 8.5-fluid-ounce bottles for a fraction of the cost that other similar options offer.
  • moderately complex taste
  • tall elegant presentation
  • not aged long enough
Brand Villa Manodori
Model pending
Weight 3.3 pounds
Rating 4.2 / 5.0
4
The Compagnia Del Montale has been matured through slow acetification, derived from natural fermentation and progressive concentration in a series of small barrels. This gives the final product a rich, thick consistency that is reminiscent of syrup.
  • dark and glossy color
  • no addition of aromatic substances
  • regionally sealed
Brand Compagnia del Montale
Model 305-0
Weight 1.1 pounds
Rating 4.2 / 5.0
3
Guaranteed by the Consortium of Traditional Balsamic Vinegar Producers in Modena, Italy, the Balsamic Guy Tradizionale Extra Vecchio is made with nothing but pure cooked grape must, providing you with the most refined taste possible.
  • aged in wooden barrels for 25 years
  • includes a pourer
  • elegant and exclusive glass bottle
Brand The Balsamic Guy
Model pending
Weight 1.4 pounds
Rating 4.8 / 5.0
2
The Cavalli Tradizionale of Reggio Emilia is independently produced by Giovanni Cavalli. This gold seal bottle has been aged 75 years to achieve a density and a sweetness to its overall structure that set it apart from other options.
  • rich and complex flavors
  • each one is numbered
  • refined in three wood casks
Brand Cavalli
Model pending
Weight 1.6 pounds
Rating 4.5 / 5.0
1
The Mussini Grande Vecchio has been aged more than 100 years and has a flavor smooth enough that it can be eaten with a spoon as an unusual aperitif. It also pairs nicely with meats, fish, raw vegetables, cheeses, and fruit.
  • works as an after-dinner liqueur
  • produced in the fertile modena plain
  • quality standards are extremely high
Brand Mussini
Model M1940-1
Weight 12.8 ounces
Rating 5.0 / 5.0

Buyer's Guide

How Balsamic Vinegar Is Made

Similar to champagne, which can only be produced in the Champagne region of France, true balsamic vinegar can only be produced in a particular geographic location, this being the Modena and Reggio regions of Italy.

The first known reference to balsamic vinegar comes from 1046, when Emperor Enrico III was given a bottle as a gift. During the Middle Ages, it was considered a cure all and used for everything from labor pains to sore throats.

Unlike many other vinegars, balsamic is not made from wine. Instead, it is an aged reduction made from three particular grape varieties: Lamrusco, Trebbiano, and Spergola. These grapes are pressed and slowly boiled down in a large copper kettle until the water content is reduced by 50% or more. This results in a must, which is then placed into wooden barrels to age. Some already aged balsamic vinegar is also added to assist in acetification.

The only woods approved for aging balsamic vinegar are oak, chestnut, juniper, ash, cherry, mulberry, and a cacia. Each year, as the must in the barrels evaporates, it is transferred into smaller barrels, each of these is made from one of the different woods listed above. This allows them to pick up different flavor nuances from each type of wood during the process. When the balsamic vinegar is sold, it is divided into three different age categories; young is from 3 to 5 years, middle-aged is from 6 to 12 years, and old is from 12+ years. Some of the most expensive balsamic vinegars can be over 100 years old.

Health Benefits Of Balsamic Vinegar

Balsamic vinegar offers a range of health benefits that cannot be found in many other commonly used vinegars. These many health benefits are most likely what led to its reputation as a cure all in the middle ages. Those with high blood pressure will be happy to learn that balsamic vinegar can help to lower and stabilize blood pressure.

It reduces atherosclerosis, which is a hardening of the arteries that is commonly responsible for high blood pressure. Researchers have found that animals who consumed vinegar regularly had lower systolic blood pressure levels. Balsamic vinegar also contains a high amount of antioxidants, which can help repair damaged caused by free radicals in cells and protect the body from cancer and heart disease.

In addition to stabilizing blood pressure, balsamic vinegar can stabilize cholesterol by limiting the ability of harmful LDL cholesterol to oxidize, reducing the damage it can do. Balsamic vinegar is also low on the glycemic index, which is a scale for the effect of food on blood sugar levels. Foods with a low glycemic index don't cause spikes in blood sugar, making them safe for diabetics, and healthy for everybody.

The iron, potassium, calcium, and manganese in balsamic vinegar can help improve the body's ability to lose weight. This can make it especially beneficial to those on a diet who are looking to drop a few pounds. Along with improving the body's ability to lose weight, it can help digestion. Vinegar boosts pepsin activity, which is the enzyme that breaks down protein into amino acids so it can be more easily absorbed by the body.

How To Choose A Balsamic Vinegar

True balsamic vinegar is expensive, but those who have had it before know that it is worth every penny. All high quality balsamic vinegar will be labeled as either "Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale di Reggio Emilia" or "Aceto Balsamico Tradizionale di Modena". This translates to traditional balsamic vinegar of Reggio Emilia and traditional balsamic vinegar of Modena, respectively.

If they have one of the these, labels than you can be assured they were produced to the exacting standards mentioned above. You should also look for the Denominazione di orgine controllata (DOC) number and seal, which indicates that it is approved by the Consorzio Aceto Balsamico di Modena (Consortium of Balsamic Vinegar of Modena.)

Some great balsamic vinegar manufacturers sell their product without the DOC label, which means that one should also double check the ingredient list before writing off a particular brand. When examining the ingredient label, one should see the must of grapes as the first ingredient, not vinegar as one might expect. Good quality balsamic vinegar will also not have any caramel or flavorings of any kind added. Also look for a notation somewhere on the bottle that specifics the vinegar in questions has been "aged in wooden barrels", not just "aged in wood." Lower quality manufacturers often just add wood chips to their vinegar so they can put "aged in wood" on their bottles.

Don't be mislead by lower quality balsamic vinegar labeled as "Aceto Balsamico di Modena" or "Balsamic Vinegar of Modena". Unless it has the word tradizionale or traditional, it is an imitation balsamic vinegar that is made from vinegar and not grape must. It is important to look for every indication of a true balsamic vinegar as manufacturers go to great lengths to trick consumers into buying lower quality imitations. For example, some make a balsamic vinegar that is actually a combination of red wine vinegar and grape must from traditional balsamic vinegar. This may allow them to get away with using grape must as the first ingredient on the label, but they usually aren't aged and won't have the complexity of true balsamic vinegar.



Statistics and Editorial Log

0
Paid Placements
4
Editors
33
Hours
18,692
Users
39
Revisions

Revision History


Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page. For our full ranking methodology, please read 'about this wiki', linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.
Last updated on April 21 2017 by Daniel Imperiale

Daniel is a writer, actor, and director living in Los Angeles, CA. He spent a large portion of his 20s roaming the country in search of new experiences, taking on odd jobs in the strangest places, studying at incredible schools, and making art with empathy and curiosity.