The 10 Best Colored Pencil Sets

Updated March 12, 2018 by Jordan Melcher

10 Best Colored Pencil Sets
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive
We spent 45 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top choices for this wiki. Whether you're looking for a fun pastime for your kids or are a serious artist or art student needing supplies, one of these colored pencil sets should suit you nicely. We've included both affordable and professional-quality options, as well as water-soluble and oil-based versions. You can use these to craft your latest masterpiece or to simply de-stress with a coloring book. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best colored pencil set on Amazon.

10. Castle Art Supplies Premium

If you're just getting started on the path towards becoming a fully-fledged artist, the Castle Art Supplies Premium will see you off in the right direction. You can take this set anywhere you please, thanks to the attractive and compact tin box.
  • wide range of color possibilities
  • soft design is ideal for layering
  • trays are difficult to remove
Brand Castle Art Supplies
Model pending
Weight 1.6 pounds
Rating 3.7 / 5.0

9. LyraA Rembrandt Polycolor

The LyraA Rembrandt Polycolor is a handsome looking option with pencils that feature a natural woodgrain finish. You can choose from sets ranging from 12 to 105 pencils, so there is one for every need. Each comes with a protective storage case.
  • good for use on a variety of mediums
  • lots of nuanced color tones
  • lacking pink and purple shades
Brand Lyra
Model 2001720
Weight 1.5 pounds
Rating 3.7 / 5.0

8. Art 101 53142

Why stop with colored pencils alone when you can get a range of drawing and painting mediums for the same price? The Art 101 53142 is more than suitable for youngsters or the average novice, like someone looking to get into adult coloring books.
  • includes wooden storage case
  • easy to keep organized
  • crayons are low quality
Brand Art, Inc.
Model 53142
Weight 5.7 pounds
Rating 3.8 / 5.0

7. Derwent Coloursoft

The Derwent Coloursoft work well for blending, making them a smart choice for artists who desire smooth color gradation. The set comes with a good mix of deep colors and soft pastel hues, and each pencil has a thick, sturdy barrel to offer a secure grip.
  • stores in a tough metal tin
  • perfect for still-life or landscapes
  • not ideal for skin tones
Brand Derwent
Model 701029
Weight 2.2 pounds
Rating 4.2 / 5.0

6. Thornton's Art Supply 01504

While some professionals may believe that the Thornton's Art Supply 01504 isn't the best quality, the average art enthusiast certainly won't be able to feel or see a distinction. With a total of 150 pencils for just under $60, it is an incredible value.
  • work well for color mixing
  • arrive presharpened
  • includes multiple pencil types
Brand Thornton's Art Supplies
Model FBA_TAS-01504
Weight 3.2 pounds
Rating 4.4 / 5.0

5. Faber-Castell 110024

The Faber-Castell 110024 is a small but professional quality option that comes in at an affordable price; they must know something about being a broke, struggling artist. These oil-based pencils produce a very smooth and rich color on all types of surfaces.
  • great for detail work and blending
  • won't break after sharpening
  • require little to no pressure
Brand Faber-Castel
Model 110024
Weight 9.9 ounces
Rating 4.3 / 5.0

4. Imaginesty IM

The Imaginesty IM doesn't just have bold colors, but also makes a bold claim: you will be 100% satisfied with these or you will get 100% of your money back, no questions asked. Their cream-textured leads work well for detail lines and color blending.
  • budget-friendly price
  • made with nontoxic materials
  • great for advanced artists
Brand Imaginesty
Model IM
Weight 10.1 ounces
Rating 4.9 / 5.0

3. JNW Direct Jazmine

The JNW Direct Jazmine is a good set for youngsters, as it includes a large sampling of colors and comes with a roll-up case that can fit inside a school backpack. It even includes a special eraser that makes it easy to fix mistakes.
  • metal pencil extender
  • hexagonal barrels
  • each is clearly labeled by color
Brand JNW Direct
Model Jazmine Set
Weight 15.5 ounces
Rating 4.5 / 5.0

2. Prismacolor Premier

The bodies of the pencils in the Prismacolor Premier are all the exact same color as their leads, which makes for quicker identification when sorting through them. Their soft cores make them well-suited to shading and shadow work.
  • very intense pigments
  • multiple shades of each color
  • resistant to breaking and chipping
Brand Prismacolor
Model 4484
Weight 2.8 pounds
Rating 4.9 / 5.0

1. Faber-Castell Polychromos 120

Unless you are a professional artist or dedicated art student, the Faber-Castell Polychromos 120 is probably higher quality than you need. For the committed few who demand the very best from their supplies, this is exactly what you are looking for.
  • extremely vibrant colors
  • leads are perfectly centered
  • oil-based and completely waterproof
Brand Faber-Castell
Model FC110013
Weight 8.6 pounds
Rating 4.6 / 5.0

The Myriad Advantages of Working With a Colored Pencil Set

Colored pencils have only been around for a fraction of the time that paint and artist's charcoal have - a fact which might explain why colored pencils are often afforded such short shrift. This is unfortunate, especially considering that colored pencils can offer an entire litany of advantages, even if an artist is only using this medium to create an early mock-up of his work.

Consider, as an example, that the point of a colored pencil allows for greater precision than almost any other handheld implement. Colored pencils also feature UV-resistant pigment, meaning that while a sheet of paper may fade due to sunlight, the pigment that is left there by a colored pencil will not.

Working in colored pencil means that there's no need for any prep work or clean-up. Colored pencils are self-sufficient, in that an artist doesn't need anything more than a canvas or a page in order to get to work. What's more, these pencils take up little space, and they don't produce fumes, like certain paints, or a marker can.

Artist-grade colored pencil sets can feature up to 120 shades, displayed in a consecutive array like swatches. These sets are sold in cases, rendering them entirely portable, and they're ideal for taking with you on a road trip, or for sketching freehand in the park.

How to Care for & Preserve Your Colored Pencils

Most people who own a colored-pencil set have their favorite colors, which they consistently use without a lot of forethought. While this may be convenient, it doesn't bode well for maintaining a complete set of pencils, long-term. For in the end you wind up with 90% of your pencils completely unused, while the other 10% have been worn down to a nub.

The first way to avoid this is by designating secondary colors for everyday use. If you're accustomed to using a primary red, for example, then perhaps you should switch to a shade of red that you wouldn't otherwise try. This way you can preserve most of your primary colors, while getting use out of some of your secondary colors at the same time.

Much like a crayon that picks up resin from another color's wax, tracing over one shade of wax- or oil-based color pencil can tarnish the color and quality of another. That being the case, you'll want to be sure and wipe down the tips of any pencils that have been used to blend colors or fine-tune a shade. You'll also want to invest in a kneaded eraser, which you can use whenever "knead" be.

Ideally, you'll want to use a utility knife to sharpen the point of any colored pencils. Mechanical and electrical sharpeners tend to shave off a lot of unnecessary wood. On top of which, wax-based pencils can cause a pencil sharpener to jam. Utility knives, when used correctly, are not only efficient, but they'll provide your pencils with a much finer point, as well.

How The Colored Pencil Came To Be

The word pencil, meaning little tail, was initially used to refer to the bristles of an artist's brush. That began to change, however, during the 16th Century, after British prospectors discovered graphite while excavating a series of mines beneath Grey Knotts.

The British Government immediately seized these mines, intent on using graphite as a resource for building armaments. Civilian use of graphite was strictly prohibited, a fact which did not stop British artists from breaking in and stripping the mines. These bandits soon found that there was an issue with using graphite for artistic purposes in that the composition was soft, and it would often break if grasped too hard.

That problem was solved by an Italian couple in 1560. Inspired by draftsmen who had taken to wrapping graphite between sheepskin, this couple experimented with encasing graphite inside an oval piece of wood. The result gave birth to what affectionately became known as the graphite pencil - an industry that England lorded over as a result of owning the only supply.

As it turned out, powdered graphite was abundant across any number of continents. And during the 1800s, several entrepreneurs began refining powdered graphite into a hardened form. One of these entrepreneurs, an American named Joseph Dixon, came up with a process for mass producing graphite pencils at a meager cost. Dixon died in 1869, but the company that he founded, Dixon Ticonderoga, was already on the verge of becoming the largest pencil manufacturer in the world.

Given the viability of wooden pencils, it wasn't long before manufacturers began to use wax, as opposed to graphite, for developing colored pencils, as well. The first colored pencils were introduced by a German company named Faber-Castell in 1908. Despite some initial success, the watershed moment for colored pencils didn't occur until 30 years later, when a company named Prismacolor came to market with a line of pencils that transformed the concept from passing novelty to artist prestige.

Today, colored pencils remain popular. These pencils are largely sold to artists, fashion designers, graphic designers, and advertisers, but they are also marketed to college students, along with families with young kids.

Statistics and Editorial Log

Paid Placements

Recent Update Frequency

help support our research

patreon logoezvid wiki logo small

Last updated on March 12, 2018 by Jordan Melcher

Born in California, Jordan moved all over the country before deciding that maybe he should just come back to the Golden State and stay for a bit. He’s a writer and musician who holds strong opinions about most things.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.