The 10 Best Mechanical Pencils
Special Honors
Graf von Faber Castell Guilloche Made via an engraving process usually reserved for jewelry or silver accessories, the Graf von Faber Castell Guilloche is certainly a premium option. It features a hand-lacquered barrel in your choice of cognac, anthracite, black, or rhodium, with no two being identical, so you are getting a truly one of kind piece. graf-von-faber-castell.com
Cleo Skribent SilverSign Crafted from sterling silver, the Cleo Skribent SilverSign is a beautiful writing implement from a nearly 80-year old company. It features a hexagonal barrel that provides a secure grip and has a reliable push-retract mechanism. Take note though, it will require periodic polishing so that it doesn't tarnish. fendrihan.com
Wyrmwood Bolivian Rosewood Pencil The Wyrmwood Bolivian Rosewood Pencil has a classic contoured form more often seen in collectible pens that pencils that makes it feel very natural in the hand when writing. While we have chosen to highlight the rosewood model due to the tonal depth and character it offers, it is available in other woods too. wyrmwoodgaming.com
Editor's Notes
February 15, 2021:
Though some may be surprised to learn this, the first mechanical pencil was actually developed nearly 200 hundred years ago. In that time, a lot of different designs and mechanisms have come and gone though the basic principle has remained mostly the same. These days, nearly all of the models on the market utilize a rotating or spring-based action to send lead out through the tip.
We believe that anyone who finds themselves on this list isn't looking for the basic Bic or Papermate model found in pretty much every every middle or high school kid's backpack, which is why you won't find anything like that here. Instead, we have focused on high-quality options that have slightly more refined designs, and often additional features that make them more efficient to use. For example, we have the Rotring Rapid Pro and Zebra Stainless Steel, both of which have metallic bodies worthy of professionals. And while the former might be a bit expensive for some, the latter certainly comes for a reasonable price.
At this time, we have chosen not to replace any of our currently recommended models, as we feel they still represent the best options on the market, without getting into the exorbitantly priced pencils that would only appeal to connoisseurs. That being said, we have decided to add a couple of those kinds to our special honors section, just in case you fall into this category and came here hoping to find a new one for your growing collection.
October 04, 2019:
You might be surprised at how enthusiastic some people are about their pencils, and no matter what you're using it for, there's probably one that will get you at least a little excited. If you're working on a DIY project you'll want something like the FastCap, though for more precise or technical projects you might want to go with the Staedtler, a longtime beloved manufacturer of writing utensils. The Autopoint Twin is another relatively specialized model that's ideal for anyone grading papers or making notes on their own rough draft.
If you're going for an inexpensive and lightweight option that's comfortable for all-day use, the Pentel Sharp is one of the most well-known such choices around. The Zebra is a little less popular but you may actually prefer how it feels in the hand. For a little more money you can move to an innovative rotating model like the Uni-Ball Kuru Toga or the slightly upgraded Roulette, both of which keep your writing a consistent width while making it less likely you'll poke holes in the paper. For serious drafting, many engineers really like the Graph Gear 1000 thanks in part to its hefty metal barrel. The Rotring is a good compromise between a heavy drafting pencil and a lightweight note-taking utensil. If you really want to get fancy, check out the Pentel Orenz Nero, which combines some of the best parts of all the options into one luxurious, albeit expensive device.