The 10 Best Nativity Sets

Updated December 03, 2017 by Tina Morna Freitas

10 Best Nativity Sets
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive
We spent 43 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top choices for this wiki. Looking to add to your Christmas decorations for this year? Consider one of these nativity sets, all featuring the classic story, some with whimsical scenes and some with exquisite figurines. The origin of this traditional display is credited to Saint Francis of Assisi and dates back to 1223, continuing a long history of celebrating the birth of Jesus. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best nativity set on Amazon.

10. Collections Etc. Flameless Candles

For a simple first Christmas scene without having to worry about lost figurines or small pieces falling over, the Collections Etc. Flameless Candles feature the story of Jesus' birth in beautiful silhouette. You get a nice warm glow without the danger of an open flame.
  • includes three candles
  • smaller than they appear in photos
  • light is a bit dim
Brand Collections Etc
Model pending
Weight 1.9 pounds
Rating 4.2 / 5.0

9. Following the Star

Inspired by the art of Thomas Kinkade, the gorgeous Following the Star by Hawthorne Village is a feast of movement and music for the senses. It plays four Christmas carols and has rotating figurines. The background buildings reflect how Bethlehem looked 2000 years ago.
  • giant crystalline star
  • mahogany-finish base
  • very expensive for its small size
Brand Hawthorne Village
Model 14-01680-001
Weight 6.8 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

8. Holy Land Market Miniature

If you prefer a more rustic-looking set, the Holy Land Market Miniature is made from hand-carved olive wood and comes straight from Bethlehem to your door, making it ideal for traditionalists. It also comes with a certificate of origin and a prayer card.
  • arrange the pieces however you like
  • ideal for small spaces
  • faces have nondescript features
Brand Holy Land Market
Model 6118477
Weight 1.9 pounds
Rating 3.9 / 5.0

7. Kurt Adler 7 Piece

The Kurt Adler 7 Piece features a vintage style that will make this set seem like a timeworn family heirloom, right down to the rustic stable in the background. It's actually made from durable resin so you don't have to worry if you have rambunctious kids playing nearby.
  • detailed facial expressions
  • realistic flesh tones
  • grass on the stable can flake off
Brand Kurt Adler
Model C7104
Weight 5.7 pounds
Rating 4.4 / 5.0

6. Lenox First Blessing Holy Family

The Lenox First Blessing Holy Family is an elegant option that you can fit atop almost any table or dresser in your home. It's crafted of porcelain and has real 24K gold accents, making it an heirloom your family will cherish for generations.
  • lifetime breakage replacement
  • intricate hand-painted details
  • lots of matching pieces available
Brand Lenox
Model 6238430
Weight 2.2 pounds
Rating 4.8 / 5.0

5. Teak Isle Outdoor

The Teak Isle Outdoor has a graceful, understated simplicity, depicting the Christmas scene in unadulterated, pale white silhouettes that make it a great addition to your outdoor decor. It's visible day or night, and is made from durable marine-grade plastic.
  • does not look overly commercial
  • packs down for easy storage
  • needs more support in high winds
Brand Teak Isle Outdoor
Model pending
Weight pending
Rating 4.4 / 5.0

4. Brubaker Christmas Pyramid

The lovely Brubaker Christmas Pyramid is a unique take on the nativity scene that most people will not have seen before. It is an 18-inch-tall nativity play comprised of a 3-tiered carousel that whirls about when candles are lit in its holders, causing the blades to turn.
  • exclusive design from germany
  • wonderful play of light and shadow
  • instructions are in german only
Model Weihnachtspyramide45cm
Weight 2 pounds
Rating 3.8 / 5.0

3. Fisher-Price Little People

The charming Fisher-Price Little People playset is a great way to introduce children to the Christmas story while letting them play and have fun at the same time. It comes with 12 figures and a stable, including the angel and lots of animals.
  • helps toddlers develop dexterity
  • plays away in a manger song
  • star on top lights up
Brand Fisher-Price
Model J2404
Weight 2.6 pounds
Rating 4.6 / 5.0

2. Demdaco Willow Tree

The versatile Demdaco Willow Tree has a simple, modern aesthetic, yet somehow manages a timeless, classic appeal. The initial six-piece set can stand alone, or you can add characters and accessories for a more complete scene, depending on how much space you have.
  • comes in a beautiful gift box
  • cast in resin from artist's carving
  • perfect housewarming gift
Brand Demdaco
Model 26005
Weight 2.7 pounds
Rating 4.5 / 5.0

1. Three Kings Gifts Real Life

The Three Kings Gifts Real Life lives up to its name with incredibly realistic figurines . The baby Jesus can rest in Mary's arms or in the cradle. The three wise men carry chests filled with actual gold, frankincense, and myrrh, along with a certificate of authenticity.
  • lighted stable included
  • exquisitely detailed clothing
  • animals are very lifelike
Brand Three Kings Gifts
Model RLN035
Weight 14.5 pounds
Rating 4.6 / 5.0

How To Properly Arrange And Care For Your Nativity Set

The first key to arranging a nativity set is determining which gospel that set has been based on. The majority of nativities have been designed to provide a general-and-yet-faithful recreation of Christ's origin story as related via the Gospels of either Matthew or Luke, both of which include specific differences. The Gospel of Luke, for example, includes the only scriptural reference to shepherds watching their flocks by night, whereas the Gospel of Matthew includes the only scriptural reference to a trio of wise men arriving by camel.

While you can use the scriptures as a guide, the protocol for any nativity set is that the baby Jesus should be positioned in the center, with Mary and Joseph flanking him. The space in front of Jesus should be left open, with shepherds, wise men, and any other figurines fanning out in order of importance. Animals should be positioned along the fringes, since they are shorter. Angels should be positioned overhead, as if they are in the sky.

When the holiday season is over, every piece of a nativity set should be wiped down to minimize any chance of dirt build-up. Bundle your figurines inside of double-ply paper or bubble wrap (avoid using newspaper, as the ink might leave a film). If your set is valuable, you may want to place all of the pieces inside a sealed container. Make it a point not to stack any ornaments on top of your nativity set, especially if the figurines have been hand-crafted. You can replace a set of Christmas balls a lot easier than you can replace a wise man's leg.

How To Transform a Nativity Set Into an Annual Tradition

At its core, any nativity set is a reminder of the true meaning of Christmas. Certain people celebrate that by placing a nativity set front and center beneath their holiday tree. Other people celebrate the spirit of Christmas by donating a nativity set to a local non-profit, a nearby school, or perhaps even a family in need.

A lot of Catholic school teachers celebrate the holiday season by having their students create their own shoebox nativity sets. Students use a shoebox as a backdrop along with clothes pins (to make stick people), felt (to make robes, shrouds, and beards), toothpicks (to make staffs), and Popsicle sticks (to make a manger and stables). Markers are used for drawing faces, and markers are also used for drawing a background along the inside of the box.

Assuming you have enough space, you may be able to enhance your nativity set by purchasing a new piece for it year after year. This way your nativity can evolve much like a Dickens Village, expanding to include a little drummer boy, a choir of angels, a collection of animals, and a nearby inn.

Some people place a Bible in front of their nativity scenes, with the scripture open to the specific passage which their set has been based on. Others drill a hole into the roof of the stable so they can place a bright bulb in through the firmament. This bulb, which is usually pulled down from a strand of tree lights above, is meant to represent the North Star.

A Brief History of The Nativity Set

St. Francis of Assisi erected the first nativity scene in 1223. Francis based his conception on the Gospels according to Matthew and Luke, these being the only two gospels that relate an elaborate birth story for Christ. St. Francis constructed his nativity inside a cave in Central Italy, and he used actual people along with living animals to create a more compelling feel.

Pope Honorius III endorsed this idea, a development which led to several similarly-staged scenes being erected throughout Europe. By the 14th century, nativities had become an annual tradition throughout the Church. Most of the live performers were being replaced by hand-made figurines; most of the outdoor settings were being replaced by wooden props.

By the end of the 1800s, nativity scenes had spread to every corner of Christendom, and they were available in a range of styles and sizes meant to accommodate the home, the church, or the office. The majority of figurines were being made out of terracotta, wax, or ivory. Elaborate sets were being sold as collectors' items - a profit-based practice which flew in the face of St. Francis' original intent.

Today, nativity sets continue to be a hallmark of the holiday season. In Christian households and in churches, these wholesome sets have become almost as recognizable as the Christmas tree itself. There is one primary difference, however, in that nativity sets continue to sell at a reasonable pace, whereas "real" Christmas tree sales have begun to drop off - a byproduct of American consumers investing in artificial trees as a way of saving on costs and clean-up, while remaining environmentally responsible, as well.

Statistics and Editorial Log

Paid Placements

Wiki Granular Update & Revision Log

help support our research

Patreonlogoorange psj5g7Wiki ezvid low poly earth xdypeb

Last updated on December 03, 2017 by Tina Morna Freitas

Tina Morna Freitas is a writer who lives in Chicago with her family and two cats. She enjoys making and sipping margaritas and aspires to be a crazy cat lady once all the children are grown.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.