The 9 Best Oven Mitts
Updated by · How we research
Silicone mitts, cotton mitts and five-finger gloves compared on timed heat tests, grip and care. The OXO Good Grips Silicone Oven Mitt leads nine picks. When users buy our independently chosen editorial selections, we may earn commissions to help fund the Wiki.
No oven mitt keeps a hot cast-iron handle bearable for long. In published kitchen tests, the best held out well under a minute, and damp cloth lets heat through in seconds. A silicone shell over a fabric lining did best, while knit gloves trade protection for nimble fingers. This list suits home bakers, roasters and anyone tired of scorched fingertips.
Editor's Notes
November 16, 2026, by Ezvid Wiki Editors:
The OXO Good Grips Silicone Oven Mitt is our new top pick. America's Test Kitchen, Serious Eats and Bon Appetit each timed how long testers could grip a hot cast-iron handle, and all three landed on it. Wirecutter's favorite, the Homwe Extra Long, stays and moves up to second.
This page is back after a break, rebuilt around those timed tests plus makers' heat ratings and care labels. We kept the Grill Armor gloves, the full-size KitchenAid Asteroid in place of the mini, and All-Clad's current silicone-striped mitt. We dropped a welding glove, a neoprene mitt that can melt, two barbecue gloves and three listings that are gone. We also cut two claims from the old guide: that cloth mitts stop at 200 degrees, and a popular story about who invented the oven mitt that has no source behind it.
Earlier notes
July 30, 2021, by Christopher Thomas:
Nothing new to report in the world of oven mitts recently. Silicone options like the Homwe Professional are ideal for working with steamers or steam-heavy cooking in general, while glove models like the Grill Armor Extreme Heat are perfect for smoking and barbecuing. If you prefer a more traditional cloth potholder, the Cuisinart Insulated is about as nice as they come.
April 9, 2020, by Melissa Harr:
The Big Red House may be simple and useful, but they also tend to smell, so we have decided to remove them at this time. And because the Cethias Mini Mitts and the Triumphant Chef Silicone have become hard to find, we've opted to remove these, as well. Not to worry, however, as there are plenty of great choices, including the popular Homwe Professional for those who'd like a rugged silicone option. They're long to cover your wrists, come in several colors, and have a liner for extra protection. This is in contrast to the Jolly Green Products Ekogrips, which have none. For this reason, the former offer better heat-resistance than the latter. This lack of liner is also why the Acronde Pinch Mitts aren't great for holding hot items for lengthy stretches; that, and they are quite small, so use them for quick tasks only.
If you want a more typical, cotton mitt, there's the All-Clad Textiles or the Cuisinart Insulated. They both come in a range of colors bright and subdued, so they'll match your kitchen decor or existing pot holders and trivets. For something a little less bulky, we added the KitchenAid Asteroid Mini, which live up to their name by offering less length than most puppet-type options. Or, for something a little different, consider the US Forge 400 Welding. They weren't made to act as oven mitts, but they offer more than enough protection to get the job done.
Special Honors
Williams Sonoma Ultimate Oven Mitt In Serious Eats' timed test, this thick cotton mitt with a silicone grip let the tester hold a hot cast-iron handle the longest of any mitt, and its slit sleeve slips on easily. Williams Sonoma rates it to 650 degrees. It's too stiff to work tongs, and it's sold through Williams Sonoma rather than Amazon. williams-sonoma.com
Hedley & Bennett Oven Mitts Bon Appetit named these quilted cotton mitts its best cloth pick for comfort and quick trips in and out of the oven. They're shaped to the hand and come in several colors and prints. They're shorter than most full-size mitts, and Bon Appetit saw some scorching after a long hold on a hot skillet. hedleyandbennett.com
Silicone, Cloth Or A Glove
Quilted cotton mitts are soft, light and cheap, and they're fine for quick, dry jobs like pulling a sheet of cookies.
A silicone shell over a fabric lining is the style that keeps winning. America's Test Kitchen, Serious Eats and Bon Appetit all picked silicone mitts after timed tests with a hot skillet handle, and Wirecutter reached the same verdict across more than 30 models since 2014. Silicone grips well, wipes clean and keeps liquids out, which matters because wet fabric passes heat to your skin fast and can let steam through.
Silicone by itself doesn't insulate much, though. The lining and the overall thickness do that work. In Serious Eats' test, the two thickest mitts held out longest, and the thin gloves gave up first. Thicker mitts are also stiffer, so a cook who handles tongs or racks may want a thinner silicone mitt or a glove.
Quilted cotton mitts are soft, light and cheap, and they're fine for quick, dry jobs like pulling a sheet of cookies. Knit gloves made from aramid fibers give you fingers, but Wirecutter found heat came through in seconds with a heavy cast-iron pan, and they fail when wet. Avoid neoprene mitts: Wirecutter says they smell and can melt, and Bon Appetit watched one's texture melt smooth on a hot skillet. For grill and smoker work, see our barbecue gloves page.
Why No Mitt Protects For Long
Every timed test tells the same story. Testers at America's Test Kitchen, Serious Eats, Bon Appetit and Wirecutter could hold a hot pan handle for somewhere between a few seconds and about 45 seconds before the heat came through. Plan where the pan is going before you pick it up, and set it down rather than standing with it.
Heat ratings on packaging, often 450 to 550 degrees for silicone and more than 900 for aramid gloves, describe brief contact, not a safe holding time. America's Test Kitchen notes that silicone starts to break down after about 30 seconds above 500 degrees, and it advises against using mitts as trivets. No U.S. standard covers household oven mitts, so these numbers are makers' claims. Some gloves cite EN 407, a European standard for heat-protective gloves.
Keep mitts dry and clean. A damp or greasy mitt conducts heat faster, which is why America's Test Kitchen tells readers to wash them. Keep cloth away from burners and open flames, since cotton chars, and replace any mitt that has thin spots, holes or scorch marks.
Length, Fit And Care
Most full-size mitts run about 12 to 15 inches, enough to cover the wrist and part of the forearm. Longer ones help with deep ovens, smokers and reaching over a hot rack. A slit in the sleeve makes a mitt easier to pull on over a bulky shirt; Serious Eats found closed-sleeve mitts from OXO and Gorilla Grip harder to slip on.
Fit matters more than most people think. A mitt that's too big slips and makes a heavy pan feel unsteady. America's Test Kitchen found the one-size Ove Glove too large for many hands, and Wirecutter noted that Grill Armor gloves run big. Gloves sold in sizes are the safer bet for small hands.
Most silicone mitts can go in the washing machine, but many linings should air-dry, and Wirecutter suggests pulling the liner out first so it dries fully. Silicone can stain, and textured patterns hold onto crumbs. A hanging loop keeps a mitt near the stove, where you'll reach for it instead of a dish towel.
How we researched this
We compared 17 oven mitts and gloves, read the timed heat tests published by America's Test Kitchen, Serious Eats, Bon Appetit and Wirecutter, and checked makers' heat ratings, materials and care instructions. We looked for patterns in owner feedback on fit, staining and wear, and we searched the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission's records for every brand here; none has a recall involving a mitt or glove. Heat ratings are makers' claims, since no U.S. standard covers household oven mitts.
Sources (8)
- America's Test Kitchen: The Best Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
- Serious Eats: I Tested 13 Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
- Bon Appetit: I Found the Hottest Oven Mitt
- Wirecutter: The Best Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
- Skeptics Stack Exchange: Was the oven mitt first developed by Earl Mitt?
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission: SaferProducts.gov
- Williams Sonoma: Ultimate Oven Mitt
- Hedley & Bennett: Oven Mitts
Frequently asked questions
What is the best material for oven mitts?
A silicone shell over a fabric lining. The silicone grips and keeps liquids out, and the lining provides most of the insulation. Cotton mitts are fine for quick, dry jobs but pass heat fast when damp.
Do professional kitchens use oven mitts?
Mostly not. Restaurant cooks tend to grab a folded dry side towel, which is quicker for brief contact. At home, a mitt is safer for heavy pans and longer holds.
What can I use if I don't have an oven mitt?
A thick, dry kitchen towel folded several times works for a quick grab. Never use a damp towel or a wet sponge, because water carries heat and steam straight to your skin.
Are oven gloves better than oven mitts?
Gloves are more nimble for racks, lids and turning food, but in published tests knit gloves let heat through much sooner with a heavy pan. A silicone mitt is the safer choice for cast iron and casseroles.
Who invented the oven mitt?
No one knows. A popular story credits an 1870s Texan named Earl Mitt, but no one has found a source for it (Skeptics Stack Exchange). Padded hand coverings for hot work are far older than any patent.
