The 10 Best Stud Finders
10. Zircon e50-FFP
- ergonomically designed
- low-priced for the quality
- not accurate through tile
|Rating||4.1 / 5.0|
9. Aikotoo Magnetic
- indicates the presence of a hot wire
- beeps when a stud is found
- edge location can be a little off
|Rating||3.6 / 5.0|
8. Zircon OneStep i65-FFP
- includes an instructional dvd
- auto re-calibrates when needed
- can't scan for metal
|Rating||3.6 / 5.0|
7. Franklin ProSensor T6
- shows edge and center simultaneously
- well-placed scan button
- works better than most on plaster
|Rating||4.0 / 5.0|
6. CH Hanson 03040
- polarized pull adds feel to sensing
- built-in bubble level
- can't indicate a stud's center
|Rating||4.9 / 5.0|
5. Franklin ProSensor 710
- can detect multiple objects at once
- simple enough for anyone to use
- doesn't detect live wires
|Rating||4.1 / 5.0|
4. Zircon MultiScanner i520-FFP
- finds center and edges of studs
- detects metal three inches deep
- uses a standard 9v battery
|Rating||3.8 / 5.0|
3. Bosch GMS120
- illuminated lcd screen
- runs on a single 9-volt battery
- ideal for professional contractors
|Rating||4.5 / 5.0|
2. Tacklife DMS04
- also detects live ac wires
- thickscan mode to find deep objects
- bright orange target indicator light
|Rating||5.0 / 5.0|
1. Black & Decker BDL190S
- detects both wood and metal studs
- self-levels without adjustment
- textured edges for a secure grip
|Brand||Black & Decker|
|Rating||4.8 / 5.0|
Classifications Of Stud Finders
There are two main classifications of stud finders: magnetic and electronic. Magnetic stud finders make use of a magnet to locate metal, often a nail or screw inserted during installation, inside of walling material. As the stud finder moves closer to the metal object, the pull on its internal magnet gets stronger, signalling that a stud is located beneath the wall. Unfortunately, sloppy construction can result in installation screws and nails being off-center or near the edges of a stud, so despite the detection of a stud when using a magnetic stud finder, one can not be sure that spot is suitable for anchoring heavy objects.
Magnetic stud finders can be further broken down into two types: stationary and moving. Stationary stud finders rely on the user to feel the pull of the magnet inside the unit, which means they can be erratic and hard to use. If the metal object is located deeply inside the stud, the pull might not be strong enough for the user to notice. Moving magnet stud detectors are considerably more effective. These make use of a neodymium magnet, which is suspended in an enclosure. The magnet can move around freely inside of the enclosure and always returns to a centered home position when not located near a metal object. As the user moves a magnetic stud finder over a wall, the magnet will move towards the location of the metal and will make a distinct thud as it hits the wall of the enclosure. This signals to the user what direction they should move and makes it easier to find a stud.
Electronic stud finders, also known as internal capacitor stud finders, are considerably more accurate than any type of magnetic detector. They make use of sensors, which can detect changes in the relative permittivity, or dielectric constant of a wall. The relative permittivity of a wall changes when there is a stud behind it. A lower reading means there is a stud in the wall. Many electronic stud detectors come with additional features for locating metal and live AC voltage.
Electronic stud finders can also be further broken down into types. There are instant finders, edge finders, and center finders.
Types Of Electronic Stud Finders
Each type of electronic stud finder is ideally suited for a specific task. Edge finders are the most basic as they only take one reading to determine the presence of a stud. They achieve this by detecting the change in density when the user moves it from an empty section of wall to one with a stud behind it. Edge finders require calibration over an empty section of wall before they can be used to find studs. If the user is unsure of the location of an empty section of wall, they will not be able to calibrate the edge finder and it is essentially useless. Because edge finders only use one sensor, they are more prone to errors than center finders and instant finders. There is always a chance that it could indicate a spot more than an inch from the stud's edge.
A more efficient way to locate the center of a stud is with a center stud finder. These use two sensors to register separate measurements of the wall's relative permittivity. Once the two readings match, it signals that the stud's center has been located. Center stud finders do not need to be moved in both directions over a stud to determine the center as edge finders do to locate an edge, but they do also require calibration over an empty section of wall.
The most recent innovation in types of stud detectors is the instant stud finder. These have multiple sensor plates, which take numerous readings simultaneously and are not hindered by erratic wall textures as center stud finders often are. Nor does the user need to sweep them over broad sections of a wall. They make use of the multiple readings and an algorithm to find the the center and edges of studs, and which regions of the wall has studs and which regions do not. Instant stud finders can also detect the location of multiple studs at once and indicate the width of found studs.
Invention Of The Stud Finder
It is believed magnetic stud finders have been in use since the early 20th century, but Richard D. Bray filed for, and was granted, a patent on February 15th of 1957. Electronic stud finders are a more recent invention, and were patented on July 25th, 1977 by Robert Franklin. His revolutionary design was the first of its kind to utilize an internal capacitor to measure changes in a wall's density.
Franklin tried selling the rights to produce internal capacitor stud detectors to a number of major tool companies, but they all turned him down. Finally, he approached the electronics manufacturer Zircon Corporation, who found it a worthwhile invention and agreed to produce and market the device. Until the patent expired in 1998, Zircon was the sole manufacturer of electronic stud finders.
Since the expiration of the patent, many other companies have started producing internal capacitor stud finders and are responsible for the continued development of the technology, such as the inclusion of an LED spotlight on the location of a stud. These new developments have made them more accurate, more efficient, and more popular than ever.