The 8 Best Warming Trays

Updated October 04, 2017 by Ezra Glenn

8 Best Warming Trays
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive
We spent 40 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top selections for this wiki. Whether you're serving a meal buffet-style or heating something up that you've cooked in advance for a dinner or party, you'll want it to reach your guests at a temperature that does your hard work justice. These stylish and functional warming trays will ensure just that. They come in a variety of materials and are available with a wide array of features to meet most needs. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best warming tray on Amazon.

8. GForce Blech

If you're in search of a basic, low-maintenance tool for getting prepared meals up to serving temperature straight from the fridge, the GForce Blech may be the one for you. Its heating surface is a high-quality enamel coated aluminum, but it may get too hot for some users.
  • includes a kosher certification
  • no temperature control
  • some units arrive dirty or used
Brand GForce
Model GF-P1021-989
Weight 12.4 pounds
Rating 4.1 / 5.0

7. NutriChef Buffet

The NutriChef Buffet includes a stainless steel tray into which its three removable chafing dishes can be inserted for a full service, professional-style buffet for your large family dinners or parties. It also doubles as a hot plate.
  • cook food directly on its surface
  • comes with plastic section covers
  • construction feels a bit cheap
Brand NutriChef
Model PKBFWM33
Weight 10.4 pounds
Rating 4.4 / 5.0

6. Magic Mill Deluxe

Available with red or silver trim, the Magic Mill Deluxe has an elegant glass heating surface, giving it an attractive glossy look. It features sides that stay safe to the touch, but it only has one temperature setting, which may not suit some users.
  • large 29-by-16-inch surface
  • can run for hours nonstop
  • gets too hot for some applications
Brand Magic Mill
Model MHP951
Weight 14.6 pounds
Rating 4.4 / 5.0

5. Broil King NWT-1S

The Broil King NWT-1S is just what your party needs to keep your guests from eating cold food. It has nonslip rubber feet and a 300-watt heating element. Food wipes easily off its stainless steel surface for no-hassle cleaning, too.
  • adjustable temperature control dial
  • 2-year limited warranty
  • detachable cord is a bit short
Brand Broil King
Model NWT-1S
Weight 11 pounds
Rating 4.7 / 5.0

4. HotMat Four-Dish

The lightweight, flexible HotMat Four-Dish features round interconnected surfaces, two of which maintain a temperature of 230º Fahrenheit to keep food ready to serve, while the other two reach 338º, making them suitable for preparing or heating up precooked meals.
  • teflon coated for easy cleaning
  • folds up for portability
  • some units burn out after a few uses
Brand HotMat
Model pending
Weight 6.4 pounds
Rating 4.8 / 5.0

3. KooK Buffet

The KooK Buffet features a large rectangular glass heating surface that can accommodate several pots or containers at once, keeping a whole meal for your family or small party ready to eat for hours. Its adjustable dial offers temperature settings from 110 to 212º F.
  • two backup fuses
  • metal handles stay cool
  • one-year warranty
Brand KooK
Model 7050
Weight 20 pounds
Rating 4.6 / 5.0

2. Oster Buffet Server

The Oster Buffet Server can be used with or without its three included serving trays, which fit perfectly over its ample 20-by-13-inch heating surface. Its variable heat control knob keeps food at whatever temperature you need to keep your guests happy.
  • pans are dishwasher safe
  • holds over 7 quarts of food
  • domed lids retain heat and moisture
Brand Oster
Weight 12 pounds
Rating 5.0 / 5.0

1. Cuisinart CWT-100

The Cuisinart CWT-100 lets you make dinner and keep it at temperature while you get the kids ready to eat. Its simple stainless steel design will complement most modern kitchens, and its insulated ABS handles always stay cool to the touch.
  • suitable for industrial use
  • slim profile for easy storage
  • surface heats up evenly
Brand Cuisinart
Model CWT-100
Weight 6.5 pounds
Rating 5.0 / 5.0

Why You Need A Warming Tray

You may be asking yourself, "Why do I need a warming tray when I can just re-heat my food in the microwave?" But experienced chefs and passionate foodies would shake their heads at that question. Warming trays play several important roles in maintaining the integrity of that food you worked so hard to make. First off, sometimes you simply do not have space on your stove to keep all of your cooked items hot and ready to eat while you finish making a few other dishes. A warming tray frees up your cooking surface, while still allowing you to keep all of your food hot.

The second reason you need a warming tray is safety. According to the FDA, there are very specific temperatures at which certain foods need to remain so they don't begin to grow bacteria. Of course, if you're serving a buffet-style dinner, you have no choice but to keep dishes out of the refrigerator for hours at a time. Food warming trays improve your and your guest's safety in another way: they keep your guests out of the kitchen. When your friends come in the kitchen to serve themselves off of the stove, they run the risk of knocking things over or burning themselves. Warming trays allow you to keep food warm while it is out of the kitchen, and that keeps your curious guests out of there, too.

The third motivation for having a warming tray has to do with the flavor and texture of your food. You most likely spent a lot of time perfecting your recipes, and you want your friends to appreciate the nuances of the food. Some flavors really pop when they're warm, but don't stand out once they're cold. Then you have ingredients, like cheese, that can curdle or harden once they cool down. You didn't work in the kitchen for hours to make a dish, all to let it get so cold that it doesn't even taste good. Warming trays ensure this will never happen.

Chafing Dishes Versus Warming Trays

If you make a lot of buffet-style meals, then you will be faced with the question: chafing dish or warming tray? Each has its merits, so you'll need to think about your specific needs. Chafing dishes consist of a frame or rack, a water pan, a food pan and a cover. You heat the water pan using either a sternol or electric heating element. Once you have heated the water to the desired temperature, you place the serving pan inside the water pan. In other words, hot water keeps the food pan, and the food inside of it, warm. A cover on top of the entire unit traps the heat inside the food pan. Warming trays, on the other hand, do not use water in any way. They plug into the wall, much like an electric griddle, and tend to feature a one-piece design.

Neither a chaffing pan or warming tray is better of worse than the other — they're just different. Chafing dishes are typically more affordable than warming trays. You also have the option to place disposable pans in chafing dishes, which makes them ideal for cooks who hate the cleanup. Just keep in mind that chafing dishes pose a few safety hazards that warming trays do not. Piping hot water is present in a chafing dish. If you use a sterno-heated model, there will also be one or several small open flames beneath the water pan. These features make chafing dishes less-than-favorable for buffets where children will be present.

These two accessories offer different presentation options, too. Warming trays allow you to display your dishes in a more formal way. You can put your serving set (so long as they're made from materials safe for use on the heating element) directly on your warming tray. Meanwhile, chafing dishes only accommodate aluminum or steel food pans, and they are usually large. For this reason, warming dishes are ideal for smaller dinner parties, whereas chafing dishes come in handy for serving large groups of people. Ultimately, you probably do not have enough decorative serving plates to hold food for 100 guests, so generic-looking chafing dishes are expected at bigger events.

What To Look For In A Warming Tray

Before picking out your warming tray, think of the ways you're going to use it. If you're simply looking for a quick way to reheat a dish, but don't want to use a microwave due to the many damaging effects it can have on your health, look for a warming tray that reaches high temperatures quickly. If you don't plan on consuming your food immediately, but rather need a way to keep it hot for hours on end, make sure your warming tray can run nonstop for prolonged periods of time. Regardless of how you plan on using your tray, make sure it features temperature control so that you can prevent burning your food.

You should also ask yourself if this tray will be more for personal use and small family meals, or for social gatherings. If it's the latter, then look for one with an extra large surface that can accommodate several plates at once. You might also want one with big handles that don't get hot so you can relocate it to make room for other plates during a party without the risk of burning your hands. On that same note, make sure your warming tray has a long cord so you can move it from one end of a table to the other without having to unplug it and find a new outlet.

You should consider maintenance and storage, too. You can put food directly onto to many warming trays, and if that is what you plan on doing, make sure your model is made from a material that wipes clean easily, like stainless steel. Some units fold up for storage and even have detachable cords. The slimmer the profile, the easier it will be to store your tray in a drawer or under a table when it's not in use.

Statistics and Editorial Log

Paid Placements

Wiki Granular Update & Revision Log

help support our research

Patreonlogoorange psj5g7Wiki ezvid low poly earth xdypeb

Last updated on October 04, 2017 by Ezra Glenn

Ezra is a writer, photographer, creative producer, designer, and record label-operator from New York City. He's traveled around the world and ended up back where he started, though he's constantly threatening to leave again.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.