Updated September 20, 2018 by Jeff Newburgh

The 8 Best Soft Serve Makers

video play icon
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive

This wiki has been updated 15 times since it was first published in January of 2017. While we all have our own favorite brands and flavors of store-bought ice cream, there is a lot to be said about the ability to customize your own frozen desserts at home using one of these nifty soft serve machines. Our selection includes models that are easy to use and capable of churning a variety of ingredients and toppings into creamy, delicious treats the whole family will enjoy. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best soft serve maker on Amazon.

8. Cuisinart ICE-45

7. Salton 3-In-1

6. Gourmia GSI180

5. Della Automatic

4. Gourmia Automatic

3. Aucma Ice Cream Maker

2. iSiler Home

1. Yonanas Elite

Why You'll Be Glad You Bought A Soft Serve Maker

It seems like every time you log online or open a newspaper today, you learn about some new, unhealthy ingredient being snuck into the common snacks you have every day.

The decision to buy a new kitchen appliance is never an easy one. We understand that your countertops are perhaps already lacking real estate, but it's definitely worth it to make some room for a soft serve maker, especially of you have children. Think of the first thing your kids want after a soccer game or a ballet recital: ice cream. After a long day of shuttling them around and sitting in traffic, the last thing you want to do is stand in line to buy them scoops — not to mention that some varieties are just getting too expensive. Skip that unnecessary stop and just go straight home, where you can make them a cool and sweet treat, right out of your kitchen.

For special events such as birthday parties and summer barbecues, you must have a refreshing dessert to serve guests. You could rent a soft serve machine, but you'll find that can easily costs you an arm and a leg. Purchasing tubs of ice cream is another option, but they either cram up your freezer or melt on the countertops when people take too long to get to them. A soft serve machine lets you better manage how you dole out this frozen delight and will keep those freezer shelves available for the single TV dinners you like to stock up on. They are also great way to promote some family time with the kids on ordinary nights.

When you make soft serve at home, you get to control what goes into your food, too. It seems like every time you log online or open a newspaper today, you learn about some new, unhealthy ingredient being snuck into the common snacks you have every day. At least when you use one of these machines, you know exactly what goes into your tasty treat. In that way, a soft serve maker can take some of the guilt out of consuming something sugary after dinner.

Why Soft Serve Is Better Than Ice Cream

If you still need some convincing to leave the ice cream camp and come over to the soft serve side, here you go. The consistency of ice cream is often problematic. It's too hard to eat when it first comes out of the freezer. Your two options are to wait for it to soften (in which case, you might just forget it's on the counter and it melts) or just gobble it up as is, but that just results in an awful brain freeze, or cold stimulus headache to go by the technical term. Plus, if it's in a cone, you wind up biting rather than licking your ice cream because it's too stiff. Soft serve comes out with the perfect texture and thickness. Just toss on your favorite toppings and it's ready to go.

It's too hard to eat when it first comes out of the freezer.

On the subject of toppings, you've probably noticed that these stay on soft serve better than they do on scoops of ice cream. The swirly ridges in the former hold onto sprinkles, miniature gummy bears, and coconut shreds much better than perfectly round, smooth mounds of ice cream. When you put these goodies on top of cold, hard scoops, you just find them at the bottom of the bowl — you can't get the flavorful experiences of having them mixed into each bite. Another delicious thing you can easily add to a soft serve cone that you can't quite to scoops is a chocolate shell. That makes the dessert even better.

Soft serve is better for your health than ice cream is, too. The reason it's so light and fluffy is that it has a much lower fat content. If you also make your own cone at home with a machine, you can fully control all the ingredients in your dessert. In addition to being easier on your waistline, it's also gentler on your teeth. Those with sensitive chompers may have found that soft serve doesn't hurt them as much as ice cream does. That's because the former is typically served at around 25 degrees Fahrenheit, while the latter comes in at around five chilly degrees. Last but not least, you have the option to swirl several flavors together with a soft serve machine — you just can't do that with regular old ice cream.

Features To Look For In Your Soft Serve Maker

When it's time to select the perfect soft serve maker for your home, there will be a lot of different options. If you want to use plenty of frozen fruit in your concoctions, make sure your machine has the ability to slice, grind, and grate chunkier items. You can even select one with a built-in cooling system that will get your ingredients cold and ready for you, so you don't need to store them in the freezer. For easy cleanup, consider a model with machine-washable parts.

As we know, children can be a bit rambunctious, so make sure your model has non-slip rubber feet.

If you're planning a special party for kiddos, complete with a cotton candy machine, bouncy house, and more, go all out by getting the type of soft serve maker that's like a mini ice cream shop. Some have a hopper that houses sprinkles, a compartment that holds cones, and big, shiny lever to serve the treat up, just like the one you'd find in an old soda shop. As we know, children can be a bit rambunctious, so make sure your model has non-slip rubber feet.

You may need to consider counter space. While some models have huge hoppers, ready for a party, if your kitchen is small, you may want a more compact model. It's always nice when your appliances match your decor, too, so if you have a more modern kitchen, you'll want an industrial-looking model. Meanwhile, brighter, more family-friendly homes might like one of the cheery looking models with colorful parts. Regardless of style, a transparent lid will help you check the progress of your dessert, and a strong motor will speed up the process. You really can't go wrong with any design you choose because, either way, you'll bring homemade soft serve into your life.

Statistics and Editorial Log

0
Paid Placements
5
Editors
30
Hours
3,740
Users
15
Updates

Granular Revision Frequency


Jeff Newburgh
Last updated on September 20, 2018 by Jeff Newburgh

Jeff is a dedicated writer and communications professional from San Francisco with a bachelor of arts in anthropology from UC Berkeley. He began his career in computer consulting and later branched out into customer service. Jeff focuses on making complex topics easy to understand. With over 10 years' experience in research, his relentless curiosity fuels a love of writing and learning how things work, and has helped to build expertise in categories such as heavy-duty power tools and computer equipment. Jeff's passion for animals affords him a strong understanding of pet products, including dog houses, beds, and grain-free foods. When he's not writing, he prefers spending time with his family and three dogs, while kicking back and relaxing with a nice glass of red wine.


Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.