The 9 Best S'mores Makers

Updated May 26, 2017 by Gregg Parker

9 Best S'mores Makers
Best High-End
Best Mid-Range
Best Inexpensive
We spent 46 hours on research, videography, and editing, to review the top options for this wiki. We all know the best part of any camping trip is roasting marshmallows over a fire and indulging in a sinful, gooey treat. These convenient home s'mores makers allow you and your family to get a delicious chocolate-filled fix anytime you like, without having to sleep in a tent or worry about swatting mosquitoes. With electric, gas and canned fuel options, there's one for every situation. When users buy our independently chosen editorial picks, we may earn commissions to support our work. Skip to the best s'mores maker on Amazon.

9. Salton SP1503 Electric

The Salton SP1503 Electric works without fire and has a durable stainless-steel housing. It comes with a detachable serving tray featuring four compartments, so you can use it for other party situations, too, not just when you're heating up dessert.
  • includes four forks
  • power on indicator light
  • takes a while to heat up
Brand Salton
Model SP1503
Weight 3.6 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

8. Hershey's S'mores Cooker

The Hershey's S'mores Cooker has a fun, whimsical design, with a fake log stand and campfire-style flames on the burner to give you that outdoor feeling. It also has a safe handle and fuel holder, adding extra protection for overeager kids ready to grab at their treats.
  • chrome-plated grill plate
  • includes trays for ingredients
  • takes up a lot of pantry space
Model NA
Weight 4.3 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

7. Sensio Bella 13578

The Sensio Bella 13578 is like a mini oven that allows you to make several snacks at a time. It has a nonstick mesh basket to hold assembled s'mores in place, so you don't have to worry about a marshmallow sliding off a stick.
  • doesn't use open flames
  • melts the chocolate perfectly
  • heating unit isn't very powerful
Brand Sensio Bella
Model 13578
Weight 2.9 pounds
Rating 4.3 / 5.0

6. S'mores Wizard

The S'mores Wizard comes with a beautiful tray made of solid wood that holds the burner and all your ingredients. The canned cooking fuel gives your s'mores that real fire flavor, but it's controlled and less dangerous than a large campfire.
  • marshmallow forks for 6
  • includes cooking fuel
  • grill must be burned off before use
Brand TV Products
Model 219
Weight 4.1 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

5. Hershey's 6203

The Hershey's 6203 is ideal for single-child households or for making a late-night snack with that special someone. It heats up quickly and is safe to operate indoors, and best of all, the grill is dishwasher-safe, allowing for no-hassle cleaning.
  • two roasting forks
  • compact and easily stored
  • electric heater is weak
Brand West Bend
Model 6203
Weight 1.5 pounds
Rating 4.2 / 5.0

4. Sterno 70228

The Sterno 70228 has a big, easy-to-clean tray with plenty of space for ingredients, and two built-in stations designed for the stainless-steel roasting forks, so you can add your cooked marshmallow and slide the fork out easily.
  • includes one can of heating fuel
  • roasting screen for protection
  • designed for indoor or outdoor use
Brand Sterno
Model 70228
Weight 1.7 pounds
Rating 4.0 / 5.0

3. S'more to Love STL611

The S'more to Love STL611 works with a conventional oven, a toaster oven, or a backyard barbecue. It can make six melted snacks at a time without the use of sharp forks, and holds them in place to ensure a perfect bake and less mess to clean up afterward.
  • spaced compartments for even cooking
  • takes about 5 minutes
  • easy to use and easy to clean
Brand Smore To Love
Model STL-611
Weight 1.8 pounds
Rating 4.7 / 5.0

2. Nostalgia Electrics SMM200

The Nostalgia Electrics SMM200 has a flameless electric heater that is safe for little ones. Just plug it in and it's ready to toast marshmallows in a minute, making this a quick option that's less dangerous than using real fire.
  • includes two marshmallow forks
  • durable stainless-steel cover
  • large ingredients tray
Brand Nostalgia
Model SMM200
Weight 1.9 pounds
Rating 4.8 / 5.0

1. Casa Moda CM10404

A sleek design and a classy look make the Casa Moda CM10404 an elegant affair that would be the perfect ending to a romantic home date night. It has a stainless steel toasting grill and ceramic ingredients holders for an exquisite presentation.
  • doesn't require any electricity
  • comes with four roasting forks
  • great for indoors or the backyard
Brand Lifetime Brands
Model CM10404
Weight 6.7 pounds
Rating 4.8 / 5.0

What Exactly Is A S'Mores Maker And Why Do You Want One?

For many people who grew up camping, a s'mores maker is simply the title for the person in charge of starting the fire, putting marshmallows on sticks and breaking up the graham crackers and chocolate bars. But, like with many human tasks, a device has been created to streamline the s'mores making process. These helpful devices come in various shapes and styles, but they all consist of some heating element over which users can hold marshmallows as they melt, or even place entirely assembled sandwiches directly on top of for grilling.

Some have special rack designs that can go on a barbecue, which is ideal for the camper who still makes meals in the great outdoors but is foregoing the use of an open flame due to the staggering outdoor fire statistics. S'mores makers often have designated compartments for all of the usual ingredients, along with roasting sticks made from food grade materials. There are various types of natural twigs that are safe for marshmallow roasting, but most people do not have the tree varieties growing in their back yard. So using the included sticks is the safest option.

S'mores makers don't only offer a safe way to make this classic treat, they also help on a rainy day. Those who want the timeless s'mores experience but live in rainy weather likely cannot keep a firepit active. An electric s'mores maker works no matter what the weather is like. They can bring the feeling of a great outdoor camping trip to one's living room or kitchen.

Styles, Accessories, And Other Features

Engaging in one-on-one activities with one's children is very important for family bonds. For parents who do not have time to sit down to a full dinner with their children, making s'mores together can be a good alternative. Parents who are purchasing a s'mores maker for their children should look for certain kid-safe features, like a totally covered heat source, and a safety burner fuel holder. For those who prefer to not keep any fuel in the house, many models are electrically powered.

One common problem that occurs when roasting marshmallows over an open flame is that they burn. There are several hazards associated with eating burnt food. Some s'mores makers solve this problem with an oven-like design that evenly heats the marshmallows from all directions. These allow the user to place their fully-assembled s'more into small cages, that then go into the entirely closed device. One of the perks of using a s'mores maker is that these devices can heat up in mere seconds.

Those hoping to create a real camping feel inside of their home can look for a s'mores maker with creative additions like fake logs underneath the heating element, or roasting sticks that look like real twigs. Marshmallows can get quite messy when heated up, so make sure the cooking element of your s'mores maker can go in the washing machine or is at least made from non-stick materials. For those who like to get creative with their s'mores and add non-traditional ingredients, some models have extra large trays for things like various chocolate bars and cookies.

The History Of S'Mores

The history of s'mores is as sticky as the treats themselves. The first documented recipe of the food was in the 1927 book "Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts." In this version, s'mores were originally named Some Mores. But many food historians argue that there were inspirations for the food as early as the Victorian Era, when elite tea party platters were often adorned with cookie sandwiches with various creamy fillings.

Some say, however, that the Moon Pie, created in 1917, was the original s'more, since it consists of two graham cracker cookies that have been dipped in chocolate, and filled with marshmallow. Others contest that the Mallomar, first seen in 1913 in New Jersey, was the first inspiration for the s'more. Mallomars are made with one graham cracker cookie, topped with marshmallow and coated in chocolate.

One can easily see how it is difficult to pinpoint exactly when the s'more came to be. What historians do know is that the star ingredient, the marshmallow, as we know it today is very different than its original form. In the Middle Ages, mallow came from a swamp plant called the Althaea Officinalis. Its roots created a sticky, sweet substance that was candied and added to foods. Since then, manufacturers have added things like sugar and gelatin to make modern day marshmallows.

Statistics and Editorial Log

Paid Placements

Wiki Granular Update & Revision Log

help support our research

Patreonlogoorange psj5g7Wiki ezvid low poly earth xdypeb

Last updated on May 26, 2017 by Gregg Parker

Gregg Parker is an author, screenwriter, and comedian who divides his time between Los Angeles, California, and Osaka, Japan. When he’s not watching sports, he spends most of his free time on his artistic pursuits or collecting miles for his next international journey.

Thanks for reading the fine print. About the Wiki: We don't accept sponsorships, free goods, samples, promotional products, or other benefits from any of the product brands featured on this page, except in cases where those brands are manufactured by the retailer to which we are linking. For our full ranking methodology, please read about us, linked below. The Wiki is a participant in associate programs from Amazon, Walmart, Ebay, Target, and others, and may earn advertising fees when you use our links to these websites. These fees will not increase your purchase price, which will be the same as any direct visitor to the merchant’s website. If you believe that your product should be included in this review, you may contact us, but we cannot guarantee a response, even if you send us flowers.